Skip to main content

Welcome to our 2024-2025 Season!

Never Better

Sept. 7 – Oct. 13, 2024

Developmental Production
Book, Music, Lyrics by Preston Max Allen
Directed by Landree Fleming

Davy, a jaded college sophomore, has been struggling to keep up with her work and social life as she faces an illness she’s written off as a cold. As her symptoms escalate, her TikTok influencer roommate April and budding “situationship” Carter encourage her to get help. But Davy’s hopes for an easy recovery fade when her doctor urgently requests she seek follow-up testing. Unable to face a potentially devastating diagnosis, Davy ignores her doctor’s recommendations and soon starts spiraling in this intimate, folk-punk musical about the value of survival in a world weighed down by grief, loneliness, and fears of an uncertain future.

This is a special add-on production to the 2024-2025 season!

The Secret Garden

Nov. 8 – Dec. 22, 2024

Book and Lyrics by Marsha Norman
Music by Lucy Simon
based on the novel by Frances Hodgson Burnett
Directed by Christopher Pazdernik

This enchanting classic of children’s literature is reimagined in brilliant musical style by composer Lucy Simon and Marsha Norman, the Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright of ‘night, Mother. Orphaned in India, 11-year-old Mary Lennox returns to Yorkshire to live with her embittered, reclusive uncle Archibald and his son Colin. The estate’s many wonders include a magic garden where friendships blossom and sorrows fade. This Tony and Drama Desk award-winning musical soars in a compelling tale of forgiveness and renewal.

THE SECRET GARDEN is presented by arrangement with Concord Theatricals.

Tell Me on a Sunday

Mar. 7 – Apr. 20, 2025

Music by Andrew Lloyd Webber
Lyrics by Don Black
Directed by Keely Vasquez

Tell Me on a Sunday follows a free-spirited young British woman who has recently landed in New York. Brimming with optimism, she sets out to seek success, companionship and, of course, love. Told through some of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s most-treasured songs, including “Take That Look Off Your Face,” “Nothing Like You’ve Ever Known,” and the title song, this intimate one-woman one-act musical journeys coast-to-coast as we watch her wonder whether she’s been looking for love in all the wrong places.

TELL ME ON A SUNDAY is presented by arrangement with Concord Theatricals on behalf of The Really Useful Group.


Midwest Premiere
May 23 – July 6, 2025

Book and Lyrics by Joe DiPietro
Music and Lyrics by David Bryan
Co-Directed by Fred Anzevino and Brenda Didier

It’s 1981 and the world is hungry for a royal wedding — but is the 20-year-old bride prepared for what comes after? Following her fairytale union, Princess Diana faces a distant husband, an unmovable monarchy and overwhelming media scrutiny. But her modern perspective and remarkable compassion galvanizes a nation, even as it threatens the royal family’s hold on England. Diana is an electrifying musical about a woman who chose to be fearless, and as a result became timeless.

DIANA is presented by special arrangement with Broadway Licensing Global

Subscription Options for the 2024-2025 Season

Subscriptions available now!
Single tickets go on sale August 1, 2024.
Also, subscribers have the first chance to add-on tickets to this year’s gala celebration!
Download Subscription Form Now

3-Pack Subscription

Includes one ticket to The Secret Garden, Tell Me on a Sunday, and

Preview Performances

Thursday/Sunday Performances

Friday/Saturday Performances

Add-on Never Better

Add Never Better to your season experience for an additional $30/ticket for Previews or $35/ticket for regular run dates.

Preview Performances
$120 3-pack + Never Better

Thursday/Sunday Performances
$155 3-pack + Never Better

Friday/Saturday Performances
$180 3-pack + Never Better

Flex Pass

With Theo’s Flex Pass, you receive 4 General Admission tickets to use whenever you want. After selecting this option, we invite you to contact the Box Office at [email protected] or call 773-939-4101 to reserve your seats.
It is recommended you contact us early in the run of the show, as tickets do sell out.

Available for $180.

As a Season Subscriber you receive these great benefits!

Guarantee your tickets to all four shows, before tickets go on sale to the public. 

Season ticket holders are guaranteed reserved seats. Single ticket holders receive general admission access. 

You have the option to attend the same day and week of each production, or to select the date that works best for you per show. 

We understand that plans change, subscribers are allowed to exchange their tickets for free!

Friends and Family will receive a $5 discount when they attend a show with you. Plus, no fees! The more the merrier! 

Be the first to know about upcoming events and all things Theo by signing up for our newsletter! 
Sign up Now!

theo uses Accessibility Checker to monitor our website's accessibility.