- Best Performer in a Leading Role – Musical — Will Lidke – Hedwig and the Angry Inch
- Best Artistic Specialization (Wig Design)– Keith Ryan – Hedwig and the Angry Inch
OUR AWARDS
2019-20 Season (6 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 2 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
2018-19 Season (6 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 4 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Production of a Musical – The Bridges of Madison County
- Best Direction of a Musical – Fred Anzevino – The Bridges of Madison County
- Best Performer in a Leading Role – Musical — Kelli Harrington – The Bridges of Madison County
- Best Music Direction – Jeremy Ramey – The Bridges of Madison County
2017-18 Season (7 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 4 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Performers in a Musical — Philip Torre and Jacquelyne Jones (Sweeney Todd)
- Best Music Direction – Jeremy Ramey – Sweeney Todd
- Best Lighting Design – James Kolditz – Sweeney Todd
2016-17 Season (11 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 2 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Music Direction – Jeremy Ramey – Most Happy Fella
- Best Actor/Actress in a Revue – Colette Todd – Honky Tonk Angels
2015-16 Season (15 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 4 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Musical or Revue – Rent
- Best Director, Musical – Scott Weinstein – Rent
- Best Music Direction – Jeremy Ramey – Rent
- Best Actor in a Supporting Role – Musical – Aubrey McGrath – Rent
2014-15 Season (14 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 4 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Musical Revue – Always…Patsy Cline
- Best Actress in a Supporting Role – Musical – Danni Smith – Always…Patsy Cline
- Best Actor in a Supporting Role – Musical – Donterrio Johnson – Jesus Christ Superstar
- Artistic Specialization for Best Arrangements – Aaron Benham, A Musical Tribute to the Andrews Sisters
2013-14 Season (7 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 4 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Production/Musical or Revue – Passion
- Best Actress in a Principal Role – Musical – Danni Smith – Passion
- Best Actress in a Supporting Role – Musical – Colette Todd – Passion
- Best Music Direction – Kory Danielson – Passion
2012-13 Season (8 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 5 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Production/Musical or Revue – Smokey Joe’s Café
- Best Director/Musical or Revue – Brenda Didier – Smokey Joe’s Cafe
- Best Actress in a Principal Role – Musical – Kelli Harrington – Aspects of Love
- Best Music Direction – Jeremy Ramey – Smokey Joe’s Café
2011-12 Season (14 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 6 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Production/Musical or Revue – The Light in the Piazza
- Best Director/Musical or Revue – Fred Anzevino & Brenda Didier – The Light in the Piazza
- Best Actress in a Principal Role – Musical – Kelli Harrington – The Light in the Piazza
- Best Actor in a Supporting Role – Musical – Justin Adair – The Light in the Piazza
- Best Music Direction – Jeremy Ramey – The Light in the Piazza
- Best Dialect Coaching – Eve Breneman – The Light in the Piazza
2010-11 Season (12 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 5 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Director – Musical – Brenda Didier – Cats
- Best Choreography – Brenda Didier – Cats
- Best Music Direction – Austin Cook – Some Enchanted Evening…Songs Rogers-Hammerstein
- Best Costume Design – Matt Guthier – Cats
- Best Makeup Design (Artistic Specialization) – Izumi Inaba – Cats
2009-10 Season (11 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 7 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Production/Musical or Revue – Chess
- Best Director/Musical or Revue – Fred Anzevino and Brenda Didier – Chess
- Best Actress in a Principal Role/Musical – Maggie Portman – Chess
- Best Actor in a Principal Role/Musical – Courtney Crouse – Chess
- Best Actor in a Supporting Role/Musical – John B. Leen – Chess
- Best Choreography – Brenda Didier – Chess
- Best Music Direction – Ryan Brewster – Chess
2008-09 Season (13 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 7 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
-
- Best Production/Musical or Revue – Evita
- Best Director/Musical or Revue – Fred Anzevino – Evita
- Best Music Director – Ryan Brewster – Evita
- Best Choreographer – Brenda Didier – Evita
- Best Actor in a Principal Role/Musical or Revue – Chris Damiano – Evita
- Best Actress in a Principal Role/Musical or Revue – Maggie Portman – Evita
- Best Actor in a Supporting Role/Musical or Revue – Chris Damiano – Jacquel Brel’s Lonesome Losers of the Night
(Our 2008-09 Season also garnered three After Dark Awards: Best Director for both Evita and Jacque Brel’s Lonesome Losers of the Night and Best Musical Direction for Jacque Brel’s Lonesome Losers of the Night)
2007-08 Season (8 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 4 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Director/Musical or Revue – Fred Anzevino – Cabaret
- Best Actor in a Principal Role/Musical or Revue – Jeremy Trager – Cabaret
- Best Actress in a Principal Role/Musical or Revue – Danielle Brothers – Cabaret
- Best Musical Direction – Stephen Kartes – Cabaret
2006-07 Season (7 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 1 Jeff Award Non-Equity)
- Best Actress in a Principal Role/Musical or Revue – Danielle Brothers – Flora the Red Menace
2005-06 Season (4 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 1 Jeff Award Non-Equity)
- Best Actress in a Principal Role/Musical or Revue – Danielle Brothers – A Jacques Brel Revue: Songs of Love and War
2004-05 Season (4 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 1 Jeff Award Non-Equity)
- Best Actress in a Supporting Role/Musical or Revue – Yolanda Davis – Spoon River Anthology
2003-04 Season (5 Jeff Award Nominations; 2 Jeff Awards Non-Equity)
- Best Actor in a Supporting Role – Musical or Revue – David Heimann – A Kurt Weill Review: Songs of Darkness and Light
- Best Actress in a Supporting Role – Musical or Revue – Rebecca Finnegan – A Kurt Weill Review: Songs of Darkness and Light
2001-02 Season (2 Jeff Award Non-Equity Nominations; 1 Jeff Award Non-Equity)
- Best Costume Design – Michelle Lynette Bush – Les Liaisons Dangereuses